
Why Is It Called a Bloody Mary? The Name's Origin, Explained
Nobody knows for sure why it's called a Bloody Mary. The "bloody" part is easy: it's the color of tomato juice. The "Mary" has at least five candidates, from a 16th-century queen to a Chicago waitress to a socialite in a white evening gown.
Two of those stories come straight from the men who claimed to invent the drink. George Jessel said he named it after his friend Mary Brown Warburton. Fernand "Pete" Petiot said a customer named it after a waitress at a Chicago bar called the Bucket of Blood. Queen Mary I, the most famous Bloody Mary of all, has no evidence connecting her to the cocktail. Here are all the origin stories behind the name, where each one came from, and which one holds up.
The Short Answer
| Theory | Who told it | How solid |
|---|---|---|
| Mary Brown Warburton, a Palm Beach socialite | George Jessel, in interviews and his memoir | Best documented |
| A waitress named Mary at Chicago's Bucket of Blood | Fernand Petiot, in 1972 | Plausible, told late |
| Queen Mary I of England | Popular belief | No evidence |
| Mary Pickford, the film star | Drink fans | No evidence |
| A mispronounced "Vladimir" | Bar lore | No evidence |
First, the "Bloody" Part
The drink is red, and the early versions were half vodka and half tomato juice. Harry's New York Bar in Paris says the drink was first mixed there in 1921, and several accounts say its first name there was even more gruesome: the Bucket of Blood.
The word itself was part of the problem. In the 1930s, "bloody" was still a swear word in Britain, which is probably part of why a high-society hotel in New York wanted nothing to do with it. More on that below.
The name first shows up in print in November 1939, in a Broadway gossip column that called the Bloody Mary, tomato juice and vodka, a new hangover cure at New York's 21 Club. A few weeks later, columnist Lucius Beebe tied it to George Jessel. Neither column said who Mary was.
Theory 1: Mary Brown Warburton and a Spilled Drink in Palm Beach
George Jessel was a vaudeville comedian and Broadway star who told this story for decades, and it's the only one with a named Mary and the drink's claimed inventor in the same room.
As Jessel told it in his memoir, The World I Lived In, he was in Palm Beach after a long night of drinking when a bartender offered him a bottle of vodka, rare in Prohibition-era America. He mixed it with tomato juice, Worcestershire sauce and lemon to make it drinkable. Then Mary Brown Warburton, a socialite friend still dressed in white from the party, walked in. The drink ended up down the front of her dress (in some tellings she spilled it, in others he did), and she laughed it off and told him he could call her Bloody Mary.
Jessel's dates moved around. His memoir says 1927. A 1963 New York newspaper account of the same story says 1930. His memoir also adds a postscript worth repeating: Warburton's boyfriend at the time was Ted Healy, the comedian who started the Three Stooges act. When Healy read in a gossip column that Jessel had named a drink after his girlfriend, Jessel said, Healy took a shot at him with a pistol. Jessel claimed it went off next to his ear and left him deaf for a week.
Why this theory leads: Jessel's name is attached to the drink in the earliest print mentions from 1939, and he told versions of the Warburton story for decades. Brian Bartels, who wrote The Bloody Mary, finds it the most credible of the name theories.
Theory 2: A Waitress at Chicago's Bucket of Blood
This is the story Fernand Petiot told. Petiot worked at Harry's New York Bar in Paris in the early 1920s, when the Parisian bar was full of American expats, Ernest Hemingway among them. He later ran the King Cole Bar at the St. Regis in New York, and he's the other man with a claim to inventing the drink.
In a 1972 interview with The Cleveland Press, Petiot said the first people he served the drink to were from Chicago. They told him about a bar back home called the Bucket of Blood and a waitress there everybody called Bloody Mary. One of them said the drink reminded him of her, and the name stuck.
The bar was real, or at least one of them was. The Bucket of Blood was the nickname of a rough Chicago saloon in the early 1900s, named for the bloody mop water that got thrown into the street after fights. Prohibition finally shut it down. Plenty of other American dives went by the same nickname, so a Chicagoan in Paris talking about the Bucket of Blood isn't hard to believe.
The details change depending on who tells it. In one version, the story goes that the customer was an American entertainer named Roy Barton. In a 2011 interview, the manager of Harry's said the patron called the drink a dead ringer for a girlfriend he'd met at a cabaret called the Bucket of Blood, a woman named Mary.
The weak spot is timing. Petiot told this version about 50 years after the fact, and nothing at Harry's from the 1920s mentions a Bloody Mary. For the full back and forth between Petiot and Jessel, see who invented the Bloody Mary.
Theory 3: Queen Mary I of England
This is the one most people assume. Mary I, also called Mary Tudor, was the first queen to rule England in her own right, from 1553 to 1558. She restored Catholicism and had around 280 Protestants burned at the stake for heresy. Protestant writers gave her the nickname "Bloody Mary," and it stuck for the next 450 years.
She's the most famous Bloody Mary in history, which is exactly why the name worked on a drink. Everyone already knew it. But no source from the 1920s or 1930s connects the cocktail to her, and neither inventor's story involves her. We put her on the side of our Bloody Mary Kit box anyway, raising a glass.
Theory 4: Mary Pickford
Some drink fans credit Mary Pickford, the silent film star who was one of the most famous women in the world in the 1920s. There's no evidence for it, and she already had a cocktail named after her: the Mary Pickford, a Prohibition-era drink of white rum, pineapple juice, grenadine and maraschino liqueur.
Theory 5: A Mangled "Vladimir"
The most creative theory says the name came from English speakers mangling a Russian drink name or customer's name, and "Vladimir" turned into "Bloody Mary." Some versions say the customer was Vladimir Smirnov, of the Smirnoff vodka family. It's a fun story with nothing behind it.
Bartels also mentions a rarer piece of bar lore: a woman named Mary who sat alone at Petiot's bar every night waiting for a man who never showed, and the bartenders named her after Mary, Queen of Scots. Like the Vladimir story, nobody has found anything to back it up.
Why the St. Regis Called It a Red Snapper
When Petiot took over the King Cole Bar at the St. Regis in 1934, the drink went on the menu under a different name. The hotel's owner, Vincent Astor, thought "Bloody Mary" was too vulgar for his guests, so it became the Red Snapper.
The new name didn't catch on with customers, who kept ordering Bloody Marys anyway. Today a Red Snapper usually means a Bloody Mary made with gin, though the King Cole Bar still serves its vodka Red Snapper as a house signature.
So Which Theory Is Right?
The dispute will probably never be settled, but our read is that Jessel's story is the best bet. The name was in print by the end of 1939, tied to Jessel and the 21 Club crowd. He's the only one with a specific Mary, and he told the same story for decades. Petiot's Bucket of Blood version is the strongest alternative, and it comes from the bartender himself, but it surfaced much later.
Queen Mary I probably still deserves some credit. Whoever named the drink, the name stuck because everyone already knew who Bloody Mary was.
Other Drinks With "Mary" in the Name
Once the Bloody Mary caught on, every variation got a name to match:
- Virgin Mary: no alcohol, a play on the original name. It's also called a Bloody Shame.
- Bloody Maria: made with tequila instead of vodka.
- Bloody Molly: made with Irish whiskey.
- Red Snapper: made with gin, the St. Regis name.
- Bloody Caesar: Canada's version, made with Clamato instead of tomato juice. In Canada it's usually just called a Caesar.
More than two dozen more are in our Bloody Mary guide.
One Bottle for Every Mary
Stu's is Worcestershire, pickle brine, celery salt, and a balanced spice blend in one bottle. It works the same in a Bloody Mary, Maria, Molly or Red Snapper: one ounce plus 4 to 5 oz of tomato juice, and one bottle makes 16 to 24 drinks. Pour a little less for mild, a little more for bold, no doctoring afterward.
Get Stu's Classic | $15The Drink vs. the Bloody Mary Legend
The Bloody Mary you're supposed to summon by saying her name three times in a dark bathroom mirror is a folk legend, and it has nothing to do with the cocktail. If you've ever searched for the name and gotten ghost stories, that's why.
How the Bloody Mary Became a Brunch Staple
Whatever the name's origin, the drink was sold as a hangover cure from its first mention in 1939, and it settled into brunch from there. Over the years it picked up more seasoning than Petiot's salt, pepper and cayenne: Tabasco, lemon juice, celery salt, horseradish.
The celery stalk is usually credited to a guest at the Pump Room in Chicago's Ambassador East Hotel in the 1960s, who supposedly grabbed one from the relish tray to stir with. Word researcher Barry Popik found celery already served with tomato juice drinks in the 1950s, so that story may be more legend than fact. Today the garnish can be anything from a single celery stalk to a skewer of bacon, cheese and pickles. See our guide to Bloody Mary garnishes.
Bloody Mary Name FAQ
Who is the Bloody Mary drink named after?
Nobody knows for sure. George Jessel said he named it after his friend Mary Brown Warburton, who ended up wearing the drink on her white dress. Fernand Petiot said a customer named it after a waitress called Bloody Mary at a Chicago bar called the Bucket of Blood.
Is the Bloody Mary named after Queen Mary I?
Probably not directly. Mary I of England is the most famous person ever called Bloody Mary, but no early source ties her to the drink. Her nickname is likely why the name caught on so fast.
What was the Bloody Mary originally called?
Accounts from Harry's New York Bar in Paris say the first version was called a Bucket of Blood. At the St. Regis in New York, it went on the menu in 1934 as the Red Snapper.
Why was the Bloody Mary called a Red Snapper?
The St. Regis Hotel's owner, Vincent Astor, thought "Bloody Mary" was too vulgar for his guests, so the King Cole Bar renamed it. The new name didn't stick, and today Red Snapper usually means the gin version.
Who named the Bloody Mary?
George Jessel is the most likely candidate. The name was tied to him in the first print mentions in 1939, and he told versions of the same naming story for decades.
Why is a Bloody Mary without alcohol called a Virgin Mary?
It's wordplay on the original name. "Virgin" became bar shorthand for any drink made without alcohol. Some people call it a Bloody Shame instead.
Want the rest of the story? Read who invented the Bloody Mary, including Petiot's original 1964 recipe.


Leave a comment
This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.